top of page

Bartonville Insurance Agency

Specializing in Auto, Home, Life, and Commercial Insurance




Treating people, the way that we would like to be treated.


Bartonville Insurance Agency, Inc. has been serving our clients since 1912. Our experienced agents have over 60 years of combined insurance experience and we take pride in the fact that we provide friendly and professional service. When you call our office, you will find that you are dealing with only licensed producers. We are very proud of the fact that our customer retention averages nearly 95% year after year.

We represent a number of insurance companies in an attempt to guarantee that we provide the best possible solution to your insurance needs. Our experienced staff has the skills and knowledge to recommend the best home insurance, auto insurance or bonds that may be best used to suit your needs. In addition, we provide financial planning products, which include life insurance, annuities and Medicare supplements. Rounding out our list of services is the fact that we offer a complete line of vehicle registration, title work, and license plate stickers.


We look forward to the opportunity to meet with you and tailor-fit an insurance program that meets your needs.


Our Services

At Bartonville Insurance, we can help you navigate the complex world of insurance plans. As independent agents, we are committed to tailoring insurance coverage to fit our customer’s needs. Whether you need coverage for your home, business, or auto, we can help you find the coverage you need. We also write life insurance policies to protect your family against unfortunate, unforeseen events.

Learn more about some of our services below.


Collision Insurance

Your vehicle is a central part of your lifestyle. It is your connection between all of the important places you go every day. We will create the perfect insurance plan that is tailored to the coverage you need.

A few coverage options include:

  • Collision and Comprehensive Coverage (Pays for damage to or theft of your vehicle)

  • Liability Coverage
    (Covers your legal liability to others for property damage or bodily injury in the case of loss)

  • Road Trouble Service

  • Additional Expense Coverage

  • Lease/Loan Gap Coverage

With Bartonville Insurance, you can drive with confidence knowing that you are well taken care of.


Your home is likely the largest investment you will ever make. You work hard for all that you have and you need to be protected in the event of a loss.

Homeowners insurance can cover:

  • Your Home

  • Other Structures on your property

  • Additional Expenses which you can incur due to a covered loss

In addition to homeowners, we also offer condo owners and renters insurance. We can help you with personal and legal liability coverage, which covers your legal responsibility for property damage or injuries that your family may be responsible for.

Give us a call today so we can create a home insurance plan that works best for your specific needs.

Buying a House


Protecting your family from unforeseen events can seem intimidating. Not only do you have to decide between options such as life insurance policies, disability income protection, and long term care insurance; you need to know how much to buy.

Bartonville Insurance can help you navigate through all of these choices. Since we represent multiple companies, we can tailor a life insurance plan to your specific needs.

Our customized solutions include, but are not limited to:

  • Term Life Insurance

  • Whole Life Insurance

  • Universal Life Insurance

  • Estate Planning

  • Buy/Sell Agreements

  • Key Person Insurance

  • Annuities

Call us today at (309) 697-2121 or fill out our contact form to start the process of insuring your family's future.



Auto Owners Insurance


Pekin Insurance


Progressive Insurance




Mike Vollmer

Michael L. Vollmer

Mike began his insurance career in 1975 when he joined the Bartonville Insurance Agency staff. He takes great pride in helping both current and future clients with solving their insurance needs.

Sharon Phelps

Sharon Phelps

Sharon joined the agency in 2006 and has over 20 years of experience. She will provide you with prompt and courteous customer service.

Architectural Structure


Bartonville Insurance


1202 W Garfield Avenue

Suite A

Bartonville, IL 61607​

Click Here to Find Us

Office Hours






8:30 AM - 4:30 PM

8:30 AM - 4:30 PM

8:30 AM - 4:30 PM

8:30 AM - 4:30 PM

8:30 AM - 4:30 PM


Tel:  (309) 697-2121

FAX: (309) 697-8839

Let us know how we can help you! Please complete the form below and an insurance professional will get in touch with you as soon as possible.

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page